| Ticket for license plate light, reasonable? - Click HERE for Original Thread |
| supeg |
So, I go to a local Boston Pizza to pick up a order. When I arrive I see two cops leaving the place going out to there car (I assume they just finished eating) so I leave my truck running and put the alarm off, taking the keys with me inside. Took about 5 minutes to get my food, and as I am comming out I notice the cops are now parked behind me just sitting there staring at my truck. So thinking nothing really of it I leave. Suddenly I see them peel out and tail me. Making extra caution not to speed, stop properly for any signs ect I drive on the way back to my house.
About 2 blocks later on a main street they put there lights on. I immediatly pull over. Two cops come over to my truck. First guy, a french guy, asks me if I know why I am being stopped (I figure it was my tint, but just play dumb) after saying no, he tells me its because I do not have a light above my licence plate... Looking at him shocked I just say whatever. He asks for my licence and registration and takes it back to him car.
He partner is still at my passenger window and starts asking my questions about my truck "Who painted this? Did you? Awsome paint job!!" and such to which I pretty much ignored him and just answered "I do not know" to all his questions in a rude tone. He responds, "Oh so its like that eh?" To which I say "If you wanted to know stuff about my truck ask me, don't pull me over with bullshit citations, you think I am going to be chummy with you when you give me a ticket?" He just leaves.
So they make me wait there 30-40 minutes, while the food I just picked up is getting cold, doing whatever they can to prolong the wait I am sure. While waiting for them I decided to look at cars driving by and notice about half with no licence plate bulbs... So they come back with a 117 tint ticket and a 67 Licence plate light ticket. I take the tickets and I am about to leave when the orginal cop that was talking about my truck with me says "Wait a minute, these tires are not legal" I explain they are DOT approved drag radials (Nitto's) and are legal, he says are you sure? I just say yes and just start driving away.
Now I know these two tickets are legit, but come-on I think this is just some jelous cops harassing me plain and simple.
My brother wants me to complain to the cop shop, and then put a complaint in with our MP, but I am not sure if I want to waste my time.
Anyone hear of someone getting a ticket for no light above the licence plate? |
|
|
| GotMilk? |
From the Alberta Traffic Safety Act:
quote: Licence plate lamp
14(1) The licence plate of a vehicle must be illuminated by a tail lamp or a separate licence plate lamp so that the licence plate is clearly visible from at least 15 metres to the rear.
(2) A separate licence plate lamp for illuminating the rear licence plate must turn on and stay lit when the head lamps are lit.
(3) A separate licence plate lamp may emit white light.
Exemptions
15 Sections 13 and 14 do not apply during daytime to the following:
(a) implements of husbandry;
(b) highway construction and maintenance equipment;
(c) portable livestock scales.
|
|
|
| supeg |
Like I said.....
"Now I know these two tickets are legit, but come-on I think this is just some jelous cops harassing me plain and simple." |
|
|
| GotMilk? |
| i must have missed that part.. but i don't understand why you're asking if anyone's heard of someone getting a licence plate light ticket? for the record, i've gotten one before on my bike, i was given the chance to fix it though... but you're right it was probably just a bitch cop that had nothing better to do because i've also had cops tail me before at night with no light on my plate and i've never been hassled until i got pulled over for speeding. |
|
|
| supeg |
Just never heard of someone getting that ticket.
Obviously they have better things to do like trying to protect the public on the northside, then giving out hurting tickets. |
|
|
| the_saint |
Perhaps if you were nice they might have let you off with a warning?
I agree though that it is a pretty weak excuse for getting pulled over. |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
So, I go to a local Boston Pizza to pick up a order. When I arrive I see two cops leaving the place going out to there car (I assume they just finished eating) so I leave my truck running and put the alarm off, taking the keys with me inside. Took about 5 minutes to get my food, and as I am comming out I notice the cops are now parked behind me just sitting there staring at my truck. So thinking nothing really of it I leave. Suddenly I see them peel out and tail me. Making extra caution not to speed, stop properly for any signs ect I drive on the way back to my house.
About 2 blocks later on a main street they put there lights on. I immediatly pull over. Two cops come over to my truck. First guy, a french guy, asks me if I know why I am being stopped (I figure it was my tint, but just play dumb) after saying no, he tells me its because I do not have a light above my licence plate... Looking at him shocked I just say whatever. He asks for my licence and registration and takes it back to him car.
He partner is still at my passenger window and starts asking my questions about my truck "Who painted this? Did you? Awsome paint job!!" and such to which I pretty much ignored him and just answered "I do not know" to all his questions in a rude tone. He responds, "Oh so its like that eh?" To which I say "If you wanted to know stuff about my truck ask me, don't pull me over with bullshit citations, you think I am going to be chummy with you when you give me a ticket?" He just leaves.
So they make me wait there 30-40 minutes, while the food I just picked up is getting cold, doing whatever they can to prolong the wait I am sure. While waiting for them I decided to look at cars driving by and notice about half with no licence plate bulbs... So they come back with a 117 tint ticket and a 67 Licence plate light ticket. I take the tickets and I am about to leave when the orginal cop that was talking about my truck with me says "Wait a minute, these tires are not legal" I explain they are DOT approved drag radials (Nitto's) and are legal, he says are you sure? I just say yes and just start driving away.
Now I know these two tickets are legit, but come-on I think this is just some jelous cops harassing me plain and simple.
My brother wants me to complain to the cop shop, and then put a complaint in with our MP, but I am not sure if I want to waste my time.
Anyone hear of someone getting a ticket for no light above the licence plate?
What will your complaint be? That the pulled you over for not having the required equipment on your vehicle, and while they were at it complimented your paint job?
In Canada, in order for something to be harassment, you must be treated differently, singled out in some way. Has this happened to you several times or once? If once, you'd have a hard time pleading harassment. Police can follow anyone for any reason. There's nothing you can do about it. Unless they follow you outside of public highways (ie onto private property, then they need a reason) .If they pull you over day in and day out, you might have grounds for a harassment case, but bear in mind that if you press harassment charges against them, you carry the burden of proof, and you have to show sufficient evidence that they were harassing you, something you'd have problems with.
I can understand you were upset, but snapping at the cops didn't help your case, espcially considering the one asking the questions wasn't the one writing the tickets. He was probably a rookie along for the ride or something, and he was just trying to be friendly. I doubt they pulled you over to ask about your paint job. Like you said, they have better things to do than that.
As for the ticket...they can't stop everyone. In fact, they may stop very few. There are a lot of tickets that can be issued that aren't every day a cop shows up for work and patrols. Every now and then it is issued. Sucks you got nailed for it out of the thousands of people out there with no licence plate light, but it really is a fair ticket, and there's nothing you can do about it. |
|
|
| supeg |
You are right, it is a legit ticket like I said, but its one that is rarely given out except by assholes like that guy with nothing better to do.
It is the same as those losers that give "Improper plate attachment" or whatever tickets when there plate is only attached with one screw.
Was I singled out? I think I sure was, due to how my truck looks...
Can I prove it? Well of course not, but I will be going to my MLA to file a complaint, so obviously they will get in touch with the cops and hopefully they get reamed at the very least for eating on the job.
Now I know how all you import guys feel when you say you get stopped for no reason and get bogus tickets.
quote: Originally posted by dtjohnst
What will your complaint be? That the pulled you over for not having the required equipment on your vehicle, and while they were at it complimented your paint job?
In Canada, in order for something to be harassment, you must be treated differently, singled out in some way. Has this happened to you several times or once? If once, you'd have a hard time pleading harassment. Police can follow anyone for any reason. There's nothing you can do about it. Unless they follow you outside of public highways (ie onto private property, then they need a reason) .If they pull you over day in and day out, you might have grounds for a harassment case, but bear in mind that if you press harassment charges against them, you carry the burden of proof, and you have to show sufficient evidence that they were harassing you, something you'd have problems with.
I can understand you were upset, but snapping at the cops didn't help your case, espcially considering the one asking the questions wasn't the one writing the tickets. He was probably a rookie along for the ride or something, and he was just trying to be friendly. I doubt they pulled you over to ask about your paint job. Like you said, they have better things to do than that.
As for the ticket...they can't stop everyone. In fact, they may stop very few. There are a lot of tickets that can be issued that aren't every day a cop shows up for work and patrols. Every now and then it is issued. Sucks you got nailed for it out of the thousands of people out there with no licence plate light, but it really is a fair ticket, and there's nothing you can do about it.
|
|
|
| mwdguy |
Enough about the tickets ....
What did you get at BP's? |
|
|
| TrevorK |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
He partner is still at my passenger window and starts asking my questions about my truck "Who painted this? Did you? Awsome paint job!!" and such to which I pretty much ignored him and just answered "I do not know" to all his questions in a rude tone. He responds, "Oh so its like that eh?" To which I say "If you wanted to know stuff about my truck ask me, don't pull me over with bullshit citations, you think I am going to be chummy with you when you give me a ticket?" He just leaves.
Here's what I don't understand.
The French guy was the one who wanted to give you tickets, while his partner wanted to talk to you about your truck. Don't you think that if you were civilized and mature when dealing with the partner that he would've been able to get you off of the license plate bulb ticket?
Don't you think that after being a complete prick to him, he then decided to find anything else he could to ticket you?
Being stopped - that's not your fault. It happens. Being given the two tickets? That is completely your fault (For not complying with the regulations, and for being a complete prick to the one cop).
Just remember, with a one-of-a-kind truck, if you complain to the police about your treatment then those same police officers will make sure you get more of it (As I'm sure you're not taking your tint off). |
|
|
| supeg |
Southwestern Potatoe skins and Homestyle Lasana :)
quote: Originally posted by mwdguy
Enough about the tickets ....
What did you get at BP's?
|
|
|
| supeg |
To a degree yes, Trevor.
But there are a couple things that happened that did not make me do that.
One, if the guy wanted to talk to me about my truck ask me as Im walking out in front of him from BP's going into my truck. I get tons of attention and care less about answering a few questions. Did he do that? No, they pulled me over in a busy traffic for some stupid thing to ask me about it?
Yes the French guy was going to give me the tickets I think reguardless, the reason they pulled me over was the light he said, he mentioned the tint as well before that, asked for licence and reg and said he will be right back with tickets, when he left the partner started talking...
It is very hard to be "civilized and mature" when you are about to get some bs tickets. Seriously, would you be all buddy buddy with a cop if you got some Exaust ticket and he was asking questions about your ride?
Thats like you smiling and being all nice to someone while they are raping you...
So lets see,
Someone,
1. Waste's 45 minutes of my time
2. Makes my food cold
3. Gives me 200 bucks worth of tickets
Doesn't sound like a nice guy to me or someone who I would even be decent to.
Could I have gotten out the ticket by being super nice to the guy, possibly, I would think a 50/50 chance, and if it didn't work I would be ever more pissed.
But really why would I have to be all nice to the guy, when he was wasting my time and his with a ticket that is never given out, I pay his salary.
But yes, I will complain, just because I want them to at least know that maybe nexttime they do the same thing, that the next person might complain as well. Im sure the tickets will stay, and 200 bucks isnt really a problem, just the principal.
Yes, my tint will be removed, because I am sure they would do that in the future, as I am sure they are a little corrupt and seriously would harass with more tickets.
quote: Originally posted by TrevorK
Here's what I don't understand.
The French guy was the one who wanted to give you tickets, while his partner wanted to talk to you about your truck. Don't you think that if you were civilized and mature when dealing with the partner that he would've been able to get you off of the license plate bulb ticket?
Don't you think that after being a complete prick to him, he then decided to find anything else he could to ticket you?
Being stopped - that's not your fault. It happens. Being given the two tickets? That is completely your fault (For not complying with the regulations, and for being a complete prick to the one cop).
Just remember, with a one-of-a-kind truck, if you complain to the police about your treatment then those same police officers will make sure you get more of it (As I'm sure you're not taking your tint off).
|
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by supeg To a degree yes, Trevor.
But there are a couple things that happened that did not make me do that.
One, if the guy wanted to talk to me about my truck ask me as Im walking out in front of him from BP's going into my truck. I get tons of attention and care less about answering a few questions. Did he do that? No, they pulled me over in a busy traffic for some stupid thing to ask me about it?
Again, you're assuming they pulled you over to ask about your truck. Perhaps he wouldn't have asked had there not been time to do so. Perhaps they pulled you over for a valid reason, aka not having a light on your licence plate and illegal tint on your windows (which they may have seen before you even came out of BPs).
quote: Yes the French guy was going to give me the tickets I think reguardless, the reason they pulled me over was the light he said, he mentioned the tint as well before that, asked for licence and reg and said he will be right back with tickets, when he left the partner started talking...
So you decided to be a dick head to a guy who was making conversation to help you kill the time because his partner was writing you tickets? They aren't a single unit, they're individuals. For all you know the non-French guy didn't really want to pull you over, but the other guy was more senior and made the call anyways. Who knows.
quote: It is very hard to be "civilized and mature" when you are about to get some bs tickets. Seriously, would you be all buddy buddy with a cop if you got some Exaust ticket and he was asking questions about your ride?
Have you ever tried to find an address in the dark when people don't leave their outside light on? It's impossible. Now shrink the address in half, make it move, and conceal it in shadows. Without a light, how is anyone supposed to report you if you hit-and-run? Or any other myriad of reasons a plate number is useful. It's not a BS ticket, it's a valid one.
quote: Thats like you smiling and being all nice to someone while they are raping you...
I see. I fail to see the comparison. If someone is trying to be friendly while their parner writes you a ticket, it's like having one of the most heinous crimes possible commited to you? It's more like being stopped due to construction and having the guy who holds the sign try to chat with you. That's a much closer comparison, since he isn't holding you up, the construction is, he's just there for the pay.
quote: So lets see,
Someone,
1. Waste's 45 minutes of my time
2. Makes my food cold
3. Gives me 200 bucks worth of tickets
Doesn't sound like a nice guy to me or someone who I would even be decent to.
1. His partner did that.
2. Also his partner, food getting cold is something I personally hope cops don't care about while doing their job.
3. Also his partner.
Sounds like you could've at least been polite. You yourself said your opening salvo to this guy was rude. Seems pretty unecessary.
quote: Could I have gotten out the ticket by being super nice to the guy, possibly, I would think a 50/50 chance, and if it didn't work I would be ever more pissed.
I doubt you would've gotten out of it by being nice, but does it hurt to be friendly to people? Especially a bystander, since that's essentially what he was.
quote: But really why would I have to be all nice to the guy, when he was wasting my time and his with a ticket that is never given out, I pay his salary.
LOL I love it when people would say that to me. You pay his salary, and what's his job? To issue citations when people don't comply with the law. They are, afterall, traffic. Patrol deals with calls usually, so you PAY them to issue "BS citations" to people who don't comply with the law. Would you rather pay them and have them NOT do their job?
The ticket is given out. You're one of the few who got caught, but that changes nothing. That's like an athlete being caught for doping during a random drug test and saying it's BS because not everyone got checked. And "this guy" wasn't wasting anyone's time. He was trying to be friendly and help pass the time while buddy did the paperwork. Maybe the 45 minute delay was caused by you being a dick, and had you been polite, 2 of your 3 points would be invalid.
quote: But yes, I will complain, just because I want them to at least know that maybe nexttime they do the same thing, that the next person might complain as well. Im sure the tickets will stay, and 200 bucks isnt really a problem, just the principal.
Again, what will your complaint be? That you were pulled over, issued valid citations, experienced a delay, your food got cold, and one of the two officers tried to make police conversation by saying nice things about your car? What principle? Your complaint will never get any further than the person you tell it to, who will probably laugh at you the second you hang out. Think about what you're saying man, and consider if one of your clients made this type of complaint to you what you would say.
quote: Yes, my tint will be removed, because I am sure they would do that in the future, as I am sure they are a little corrupt and seriously would harass with more tickets. [/B]
Whatever man. I understand you're venting, but you aren't really being very reasonable. You were an ass, you got held up. The whole "I pay their salary" wasn't a bright move. Anyone in law enforcement knows that's bullshit. That's like implying you're their boss and can tell them what to do, it shows how you feel about law enforcement. You fail to realize that what they did is EXACTLY what you pay them for.
Personally, initially I felt a little sorry for you, but your ranting is making me think there's a lesson to be learned here that you're completely missing, because you're upset you had to eat cold lasagna. *shrug* Whatever man. Vent away, but it doesn't look like you're getting much sympathy, probably because you're being as abrasive in your verbiage here as you were to the officer who was trying to be nice. |
|
|
| supeg |
Let me guess you are an officer yourself, have a relative that is one, or you are training to become one?
I am sorry, but I do not see the two of them as seperate, if his partner had a concience he would have told the officer that was driving not to stop and waste my time. Both there names are on the ticket.
My plate is very visable, always clean and it was 6pm.
Since I do not know what is going through there heads, Im making assumptions just like you are.
Only way they would notice the missing light would to see it very close up which I am assuming they did at BP's and decided to "Tail me" to get more infractions perhaps?
You say I was an ass and was held up, so I deserve it? Maybe you misread but I was an ass AFTER I was pulled over and told I was getting two tickets then get one of the people who is wasting my time and money to meet some quota try to be buddy-buddy with me, sorry I guess I am not the sort of person that gets walked over.
Sorry I do not like it when someone Punches me in the face then smiles.
I do not see how being a dick is not answering the guy's questions about my ride, should I have gotten down on my hands and knees and sucked him off to get out of the ticket as well? Should I have said "Thank you kind sir, have yourself a nice night!!!" after he handed me my tickets?
quote: Originally posted by dtjohnst
Again, you're assuming they pulled you over to ask about your truck. Perhaps he wouldn't have asked had there not been time to do so. Perhaps they pulled you over for a valid reason, aka not having a light on your licence plate and illegal tint on your windows (which they may have seen before you even came out of BPs).
So you decided to be a dick head to a guy who was making conversation to help you kill the time because his partner was writing you tickets? They aren't a single unit, they're individuals. For all you know the non-French guy didn't really want to pull you over, but the other guy was more senior and made the call anyways. Who knows.
Have you ever tried to find an address in the dark when people don't leave their outside light on? It's impossible. Now shrink the address in half, make it move, and conceal it in shadows. Without a light, how is anyone supposed to report you if you hit-and-run? Or any other myriad of reasons a plate number is useful. It's not a BS ticket, it's a valid one.
I see. I fail to see the comparison. If someone is trying to be friendly while their parner writes you a ticket, it's like having one of the most heinous crimes possible commited to you? It's more like being stopped due to construction and having the guy who holds the sign try to chat with you. That's a much closer comparison, since he isn't holding you up, the construction is, he's just there for the pay.
1. His partner did that.
2. Also his partner, food getting cold is something I personally hope cops don't care about while doing their job.
3. Also his partner.
Sounds like you could've at least been polite. You yourself said your opening salvo to this guy was rude. Seems pretty unecessary.
I doubt you would've gotten out of it by being nice, but does it hurt to be friendly to people? Especially a bystander, since that's essentially what he was.
LOL I love it when people would say that to me. You pay his salary, and what's his job? To issue citations when people don't comply with the law. They are, afterall, traffic. Patrol deals with calls usually, so you PAY them to issue "BS citations" to people who don't comply with the law. Would you rather pay them and have them NOT do their job?
The ticket is given out. You're one of the few who got caught, but that changes nothing. That's like an athlete being caught for doping during a random drug test and saying it's BS because not everyone got checked. And "this guy" wasn't wasting anyone's time. He was trying to be friendly and help pass the time while buddy did the paperwork. Maybe the 45 minute delay was caused by you being a dick, and had you been polite, 2 of your 3 points would be invalid.
Again, what will your complaint be? That you were pulled over, issued valid citations, experienced a delay, your food got cold, and one of the two officers tried to make police conversation by saying nice things about your car? What principle? Your complaint will never get any further than the person you tell it to, who will probably laugh at you the second you hang out. Think about what you're saying man, and consider if one of your clients made this type of complaint to you what you would say.
Whatever man. I understand you're venting, but you aren't really being very reasonable. You were an ass, you got held up. The whole "I pay their salary" wasn't a bright move. Anyone in law enforcement knows that's bullshit. That's like implying you're their boss and can tell them what to do, it shows how you feel about law enforcement. You fail to realize that what they did is EXACTLY what you pay them for.
Personally, initially I felt a little sorry for you, but your ranting is making me think there's a lesson to be learned here that you're completely missing, because you're upset you had to eat cold lasagna. *shrug* Whatever man. Vent away, but it doesn't look like you're getting much sympathy, probably because you're being as abrasive in your verbiage here as you were to the officer who was trying to be nice.
|
|
|
| TrevorK |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
It is very hard to be "civilized and mature" when you are about to get some bs tickets. Seriously, would you be all buddy buddy with a cop if you got some Exaust ticket and he was asking questions about your ride?
I've learned in life that regardless of how people treat you, you stand there with a positive outlook and the situation won't be escalated. Contributing negative comments can only cause harm.
In my job I deal with people all day that are pissed off about everything you could possibly imagine. But I never let it get to me, because then I'd react emotionally rather than logically.
Just like in hockey, you never take the hit head on and give up the puck. You roll with it, keep the puck and put it in the net.
quote:
Someone,
1. Waste's 45 minutes of my time
2. Makes my food cold
So are you kicking yourself for not grabbing a plastic fork at BP's?? :lol: |
|
|
| GQsmooth |
license plate bulb ticket is BS, how would you know if its out or not?
Thats garbage, fight that shit! |
|
|
| ReasonOne |
I feel for you somewhat, as I posted my latest police encounter a couple weeks ago in this Law Enforcement forum. If you get a chance to read it, feel free to do so. But I have to say that staying calm, cool and collective can help your situation immensely.
Trust me, I know what it feels like to get singled out for no particular reason (I'm more than familiar with DWB syndrome). But no matter what happens (even if you are in the right), in my experience you have to hang in there or things will go south real quickly.
To use my rant in this forum for example, I was pulled over while test driving a seller's car. He neglected to tell me that the registration and insurance were expired. If I had flipped out (and I wanted to so badly) things could have been much worse. They could have given me many more fines. They could have also thrown my ass in jail and presumed that I stole the car.
You don't have to kiss the cops ass. Answer all questions and give your side of the story in a clear and concise manner. Make it clear to them that you're not into small talk while they write you up, but don't be outright rude. In the past, I have told cops that I'll answer any questions they have for me, but don't try to bullshit me with small talk because I'm so pissed off right now I don't want to say anything I'll regret. Four out of five times a police officer will respect that and either keep it short or keep their distance.
On a few instances I have been commended by several police officers for standing my ground without being an ass about it. They respect that. Usually things will either work in your favor or at least make the officer stop and think before giving you a fine.
Cops have a lovely thing called reasonable suspicion. If they so much as have a bad vibe about you, they can pull your ass over. MOST police officers are selected because they have good reasoning and judgement and the training they receive is supposed to refine and complement that. That IS the theory, anyway. What it also means is that you are at the whim of a cop's hunch. It sucks, but those are the facts.
Lucky for us, probable cause and NOT reasonable suspicion is required for an arrest. I'm not a lawyer, so you might want to check with a pro on that.
It sucks, but that's how they make their quotas. I heard a rumor that there was talk of making promotions in the traffic division dependant on quotas. At the end of every month you're going to see a whole lot of angry people with tickets like yours.
I'd go down there and see if I could get it reduced. If they say no you've lost nothing by trying!
to GQsmooth: I agree with fighting it for sure! Unfortunately, you're responsible for your vehicle being properly equipped to operate on a public street or highway. There's no way out of that. |
|
|
| the_saint |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
Let me guess you are an officer yourself, have a relative that is one, or you are training to become one?
I am sorry, but I do not see the two of them as seperate, if his partner had a concience he would have told the officer that was driving not to stop and waste my time. Both there names are on the ticket.
I can only speculate knowing enough cops that you lost any chance you had of getting out of it by being rude.
The cop chatting might have gone back and told his friend to just give you a warning.
They still have to run your info / plates to check for outstanding issues/warrants/unpaid tickets etc, and if you came up clean they can use their discretion to let you go.
Just some observations. |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
Let me guess you are an officer yourself, have a relative that is one, or you are training to become one?
I am sorry, but I do not see the two of them as seperate, if his partner had a concience he would have told the officer that was driving not to stop and waste my time. Both there names are on the ticket.
My plate is very visable, always clean and it was 6pm.
Since I do not know what is going through there heads, Im making assumptions just like you are.
Only way they would notice the missing light would to see it very close up which I am assuming they did at BP's and decided to "Tail me" to get more infractions perhaps?
You say I was an ass and was held up, so I deserve it? Maybe you misread but I was an ass AFTER I was pulled over and told I was getting two tickets then get one of the people who is wasting my time and money to meet some quota try to be buddy-buddy with me, sorry I guess I am not the sort of person that gets walked over.
Sorry I do not like it when someone Punches me in the face then smiles.
I do not see how being a dick is not answering the guy's questions about my ride, should I have gotten down on my hands and knees and sucked him off to get out of the ticket as well? Should I have said "Thank you kind sir, have yourself a nice night!!!" after he handed me my tickets?
So you're telling me that never in your training for your job, when you were new, did you ever make a suggestion and have your trainer say "No. We're doing it this way." You're making more assumptions: namely that this guy had pull with the partner. That's not always the case. There's always a "senior" officer. Besides, don't they usually do one-officer cars in Edmonton? I thought that was the case, which means this is almost certainly a training situation.
Having a clean plate doesn't change things, and it's pretty obvious when the light it burnt out. Clean or not, try reading one at night when the light is out. There's no way you can. But the law doesn't say the light has to work at night, it says you must have one that works (I think it may say it must be on when headlights are on, but I'm not going to bother looking it up). The time of day you got pulled over is irrelevant. You weren't complying with the law, you got nailed on it. If you hadn't been an ass, I might feel for you. But I don't.
And look man, why do I say you were a dick? Because YOU said you were a dick. You said you used a rude tone the first time he asked a question. That's being a dick. He's trying to make some talk to pass the time, you snapped at him for no reason, since he had done nothing to you, since HE wasn't the one writing the ticket. So don't make it sound like I'm accusing you of being an ass for no reason, you're the one who said you were. So what if you're getting tickets? THey're VALID tickets. That doesn't mean it's ok to be rude to people.
Try being patient and having some manners. They weren't rude to you, they were doing there job, you were an ass, they delayed you even longer. I probably would've done a walk-around if you were rude. Last guy that was rude to me on the job got over $3k in citations, when he was only going to get a warning. I held him there for over 2 hours while all the citations were made. He got squirmy and jumpy so I had him sit in the back seat of the cruiser too. Why? Because he was an ass. He was more than just rude at answering questions and it was an extreme case, but I remember going to court over it. Before court he met me in the hall and made comments about wasting my time in return. So I laughed and let him know I was getting overtime and then some. Every single fine stuck. Turns out all he did was waste more of his. Being rude is NEVER worth it, whether your mad or not. And if you can't control your anger better and have to be rude, maybe you should take some anger management.
No, you shouldn't suck his dick, but maybe try being polite. You'll be surprised how far politeness will get you in this world. Getting mad accomplishes nothing. |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by GQsmooth
license plate bulb ticket is BS, how would you know if its out or not?
Thats garbage, fight that shit!
How would you know if your brake light is out? Or your rear turn signal?
You're supposed to check your vehicle periodically to make sure the lights are working. Ignorance of your vehicles disrepair is not a defence.
Besides, he said he didn't have one, not that it was out. That's a whole other ball of wax. |
|
|
| Vive le Quebec |
| Did this happen in St. Albert? |
|
|
| 95EagleAWD |
quote: Originally posted by Vive le Quebec
Did this happen in St. Albert?
St. Albert RCMP pulled me over for no reason one night... he said he doesn't see many cars like mine on the road at 4:30 am. (I was coming home from work)
Guess I should've got all pissed off, eh?
Instead, we BS'd about the car for 10 minutes, talked about 350Zs (he has one) and I pointed him here and to NECC.com.
Got a ridealong out of it, too.
Polite goes a long, long ways sometimes. |
|
|
| Vive le Quebec |
| Oh I'm not saying anything about St. Albert RMCP...I just know there happens to be quite a few "French" police officers there, and I have yet to meet a French EPS police officer. |
|
|
| Tech2 |
Guess you shouldn't have been a jerk.
How motivated to treat you well is the guy at macdonalds if you are rude to him? If you pull that attitude at customs you'll have your luggage emptied. Keep it up and you'll be visiting a quiet room for a chat with a gentleman wearing latex gloves. It's going to suck when you miss your flight.
Just for fun, try being nice to the police next time you're pulled over. Things just might go more smoothly for you. |
|
|
| Vive le Quebec |
quote: Originally posted by Tech2
Guess you shouldn't have been a jerk.
How motivated to treat you well is the guy at macdonalds if you are rude to him? If you pull that attitude at customs you'll have your luggage emptied. Keep it up and you'll be visiting a quiet room for a chat with a gentleman wearing latex gloves. It's going to suck when you miss your flight.
Just for fun, try being nice to the police next time you're pulled over. Things just might go more smoothly for you.
have you heard? what's the werd? tweety bird? |
|
|
| Soulfly |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
Uhh.. I think there is something reflecting off the truck in this picture... :dunno:
-:lol: Looks cool. :thumbup: |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
Editing the post was sneaky, I almost missed it.
quote: Originally posted by supeg
You are right, it is a legit ticket like I said, but its one that is rarely given out except by assholes like that guy with nothing better to do.
By nothing better to do, I assume you mean no one else around to give tickets to. Since afterall, giving out tickets for violations is his job. So...."nothing better to do" really doesn't make a lot of sense to me. I suppose if a bank robber zipped by he'd have something better to do if that's what you mean.
Like I said, it's hard to read plates at night, even harder if they aren't illuminated. Can you tell me why there shouldn't be a law requiring a light? Because unless you have a problem with the law itself, I don't understand your complaint. If you hit and run, it'd be helpful if bystanders could at least get a partial. Sure, maybe your truck stands out enough you don't need it, but the law is the law.
quote: he same as those losers that give "Improper plate attachment" or whatever tickets when there plate is only attached with one screw.
Yeah, because you know, making sure your plate doesn't fall off isn't very important. It could only result in the same problem as having one that isn't illuminated and can't be read.
quote: Was I singled out? I think I sure was, due to how my truck looks...
Well of course. Afterall, they pulled you over JUST to ask about your paint job, and wrote you a few tickets while they were at it. But then, you knew you'd attract attention when you made your truck so flashy, didn't you? And it's not like they treated you any differently than they could treat anyone else. That's what I mean by singled out. For all you know they randomly pick vehicles and follow them, making you not singled out at all.
quote: Can I prove it? Well of course not, but I will be going to my MLA to file a complaint, so obviously they will get in touch with the cops and hopefully they get reamed at the very least for eating on the job.
Oh, I see. Man, I'd hate to have your job. Every job I've had I've been allowed to eat on my breaks, and if I could eat without interfering with my job, I was allowed to do it when I wasn't on a break. You should complain to your MLA that your boss isn't following the law and allowing you a break for food.
They won't get reamed. They won't even get a slap on the wrist. Why? They issued you valid citations, they weren't rude or impolite, and you really have no reason to be upset. I'm not saying don't complain, do whatever you want. But your MLA or MP is going to laugh at you as hard behind your back as the professional deportment department (or whatever it's called here) is going to laugh at you. And just as hard as the cops laughed at you while the delayed you for 45 mins for being a dick to them. At most someone will mention you complained, and they'll laugh about in the shower after work again.
Look, you were rude to them, you snapped at them, what's wrong that you can't just let it go? Boo hoo your lasagna got cold. If they were rude to you or something, I'd understand, but you got dicked because you were a dick after being told you were getting issued valid tickets. And you even know you were in violation of the law when you got your windows tinted so really it's one ticket that upsets you. Seriously, is it really worth getting this worked up over? It was cold lasagna one day out of your life. Get over it.
quote: Now I know how all you import guys feel when you say you get stopped for no reason and get bogus tickets.
Except....your tickets aren't bogus. You really weren't complying with the law.
What I find interesting is that we have a photo of the passenger side, the side the non-french cop was on who asked who painted the truck, and yet I can clearly see "paintdruid.com custom paint and airbrushing" on the cover. I guess the recruiting drive resulted in lower standards including illiterate officers. ;) jk
I really love the airbrushing on your hood and tonneau cover from their website, though I can imagine you get some odd looks from parents when you drive through residential zones when the kids are out playing. |
|
|
| supeg |
Hmmm I dont see it? Unless I am blind...
quote: Originally posted by Soulfly
Uhh.. I think there is something reflecting off the truck in this picture... :dunno:
-:lol: Looks cool. :thumbup:
|
|
|
| supeg |
No sense arguing anymore, I stopped a long time ago :)
Anyways, I got pulled over for speeding the next night (Yesterday) and got let off, so yah for cool cops :) So I guess i broke out even :) Would rather get the two "lame" one's then one real demerit one.
Decided not to do anything about the tickets, but does anyone know if these two tickets (Tint, missing licence plate one) will have any effect on my insurance, or is it only tickets that give demerits?
If they do then I have no choice but to fight them.....
Also, I was thinking of removing my tint soon anyways because I am selling my truck. If I do it, take pictures of no tint and bring them into court can I get off of them? Either by saying I never had tint on (Lie) or say I took it off because of ticket and ask for a break.
I heard that people have been let off tint tickets before because they remove them, is that true?
Not worried about the money for the tickets, But I gotta renew insurance soon and want to keep my clean record intact. quote: Originally posted by dtjohnst
Editing the post was sneaky, I almost missed it.
By nothing better to do, I assume you mean no one else around to give tickets to. Since afterall, giving out tickets for violations is his job. So...."nothing better to do" really doesn't make a lot of sense to me. I suppose if a bank robber zipped by he'd have something better to do if that's what you mean.
Like I said, it's hard to read plates at night, even harder if they aren't illuminated. Can you tell me why there shouldn't be a law requiring a light? Because unless you have a problem with the law itself, I don't understand your complaint. If you hit and run, it'd be helpful if bystanders could at least get a partial. Sure, maybe your truck stands out enough you don't need it, but the law is the law.
Yeah, because you know, making sure your plate doesn't fall off isn't very important. It could only result in the same problem as having one that isn't illuminated and can't be read.
Well of course. Afterall, they pulled you over JUST to ask about your paint job, and wrote you a few tickets while they were at it. But then, you knew you'd attract attention when you made your truck so flashy, didn't you? And it's not like they treated you any differently than they could treat anyone else. That's what I mean by singled out. For all you know they randomly pick vehicles and follow them, making you not singled out at all.
Oh, I see. Man, I'd hate to have your job. Every job I've had I've been allowed to eat on my breaks, and if I could eat without interfering with my job, I was allowed to do it when I wasn't on a break. You should complain to your MLA that your boss isn't following the law and allowing you a break for food.
They won't get reamed. They won't even get a slap on the wrist. Why? They issued you valid citations, they weren't rude or impolite, and you really have no reason to be upset. I'm not saying don't complain, do whatever you want. But your MLA or MP is going to laugh at you as hard behind your back as the professional deportment department (or whatever it's called here) is going to laugh at you. And just as hard as the cops laughed at you while the delayed you for 45 mins for being a dick to them. At most someone will mention you complained, and they'll laugh about in the shower after work again.
Look, you were rude to them, you snapped at them, what's wrong that you can't just let it go? Boo hoo your lasagna got cold. If they were rude to you or something, I'd understand, but you got dicked because you were a dick after being told you were getting issued valid tickets. And you even know you were in violation of the law when you got your windows tinted so really it's one ticket that upsets you. Seriously, is it really worth getting this worked up over? It was cold lasagna one day out of your life. Get over it.
Except....your tickets aren't bogus. You really weren't complying with the law.
What I find interesting is that we have a photo of the passenger side, the side the non-french cop was on who asked who painted the truck, and yet I can clearly see "paintdruid.com custom paint and airbrushing" on the cover. I guess the recruiting drive resulted in lower standards including illiterate officers. ;) jk
I really love the airbrushing on your hood and tonneau cover from their website, though I can imagine you get some odd looks from parents when you drive through residential zones when the kids are out playing.
|
|
|
| 3gec |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
No sense arguing anymore, I stopped a long time ago :)
Anyways, I got pulled over for speeding the next night (Yesterday) and got let off, so yah for cool cops :) So I guess i broke out even :) Would rather get the two "lame" one's then one real demerit one.
Decided not to do anything about the tickets, but does anyone know if these two tickets (Tint, missing licence plate one) will have any effect on my insurance, or is it only tickets that give demerits?
If they do then I have no choice but to fight them.....
Also, I was thinking of removing my tint soon anyways because I am selling my truck. If I do it, take pictures of no tint and bring them into court can I get off of them? Either by saying I never had tint on (Lie) or say I took it off because of ticket and ask for a break.
I heard that people have been let off tint tickets before because they remove them, is that true?
Not worried about the money for the tickets, But I gotta renew insurance soon and want to keep my clean record intact.
Those tickets won't affect your insurance or driving record at all.
You know you broke the law so just pay up.
And next time you get stopped by the police don't be a dick. I have been let off of 2 speeding tickets by being nice to police after being pulled over. |
|
|
| 95EagleAWD |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
If I do it, take pictures of no tint and bring them into court can I get off of them? Either by saying I never had tint on (Lie)
You the perjury is a Federal Offense, right? Lying under oath in court is not something you want to do... they judge wouldn't believe you anyways. Why would the cops write you a tint ticket for untinted windows? You think they're gonna lie?!?
Judging by your "I got pulled over for speeding two days later" post, I'm siding more and more with the police on this one. Maybe there's more to the original situation that you're letting on. |
|
|
| supeg |
If you read what I said, I was a dick AFTER I was told I was getting the tickets.
Learn to read, then reply MMMMKay? That goes for the other idiots in this thread that said the EXACT SAME THING.
quote: Originally posted by 3gec
Those tickets won't affect your insurance or driving record at all.
You know you broke the law so just pay up.
And next time you get stopped by the police don't be a dick. I have been let off of 2 speeding tickets by being nice to police after being pulled over.
|
|
|
| supeg |
I am not going to lie in court, I said I was thinking, just as I was thinking why a company made an exotic low 14 second sports car :p I was wondering something and asked a question....
Bro if you think Cops do not lie, then you lead a very sheltered life.
I have had cops swear at me, beat the shit out of two friends twice (They were running coke and deserved it, but still) and have two different sets of friends with pending lawsuits against cops for racism against them. My best friends cousin in a cop in Edmonton, and the corupt stories he tells him insane.
Anyways, if I took it off, took pictures of my truck with tint off, and had it parked outside I could get out of the ticket 100%, burden of proof is on them in court, why not just send anyone to jail if there story doesnt match up to a cops?
quote: Originally posted by 95EagleAWD
You the perjury is a Federal Offense, right? Lying under oath in court is not something you want to do... they judge wouldn't believe you anyways. Why would the cops write you a tint ticket for untinted windows? You think they're gonna lie?!?
Judging by your "I got pulled over for speeding two days later" post, I'm siding more and more with the police on this one. Maybe there's more to the original situation that you're letting on.
|
|
|
| 95EagleAWD |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
I am not going to lie in court, I said I was thinking, just as I was thinking why a company made an exotic low 14 second sports car :p I was wondering something and asked a question....
Bro if you think Cops do not lie, then you lead a very sheltered life.
I have had cops swear at me, beat the shit out of two friends twice (They were running coke and deserved it, but still) and have two different sets of friends with pending lawsuits against cops for racism against them. My best friends cousin in a cop in Edmonton, and the corupt stories he tells him insane.
Anyways, if I took it off, took pictures of my truck with tint off, and had it parked outside I could get out of the ticket 100%, burden of proof is on them in court, why not just send anyone to jail if there story doesnt match up to a cops?
Low 14s? Please... it's high 13s. ;)
I've had a friend get his ass kicked by the cops too. Granted, he tossed a coke can into the window of their cruiser, but still.
Yeah, if you take it off, you shouldn't have to pay the ticket. |
|
|
| 3gec |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
If you read what I said, I was a dick AFTER I was told I was getting the tickets.
Learn to read, then reply MMMMKay? That goes for the other idiots in this thread that same the EXACT SAME THING.
I actually read the whole thread....
So after knowingly breaking the law and you know your getting tickets for the laws that you have broken you treat people who protect other peoples asses day in and day out including your ass with disrespect.
ok there mr cool dude. Look at me I hate cops cause Cops are wasting my time. Your wasting the cops time by having things done to your truck that you know are illegal.
I hope your truck gets stolen and you have to deal with those two cops when you go to report it and then see how you feel about the whole situation. I bet you will be real nice to them when you are filling out that report. Probably because of your lack of a licence plate light no one will ever be able to read the plate and just let it go.
It's not a good idea to go somewhere and complain about something that you know is wrong and then call all the people who just had to remind you that you were wrong, idiots. |
|
|
| supeg |
Still cannot read? If you read the thread then you wouldn't have said what you said.
Please quote where I said I hate cops..
Please, I have had like 3 of my past vehicles broken into, of course nothing was ever found.
I have bigtime respect for cops that serve and protect, but ZERO who pull someone over when they are in a bad mood with a chip on there shoulder. I was pulled over at 6pm, go out tommorow and tell me how dark it is at 6pm. They did it to be dicks plain and simple, jealousy, or whatever there motovation was, i do not think the guy checks out every car he drives by in broad daylight looking for a licence plate light... The only way he would see it is if he was 5 feet away looking for something to bust me for...
Yes I am calling you along with the other morons that said "You should have been nice, then you would have gotten out of the tickets" TOTAL MORONS/IDIOTS. Like I said again, I was rude to the one guy AFTER I was told I was getting tickets....
I agree with you on one point, I hope as well someone steals it! I am selling it soon, but if someone steals it and wreaks/parts it I will get full apraised value for it :asshole:
quote: Originally posted by 3gec
I actually read the whole thread....
So after knowingly breaking the law and you know your getting tickets for the laws that you have broken you treat people who protect other peoples asses day in and day out including your ass with disrespect.
ok there mr cool dude. Look at me I hate cops cause Cops are wasting my time. Your wasting the cops time by having things done to your truck that you know are illegal.
I hope your truck gets stolen and you have to deal with those two cops when you go to report it and then see how you feel about the whole situation. I bet you will be real nice to them when you are filling out that report. Probably because of your lack of a licence plate light no one will ever be able to read the plate and just let it go.
It's not a good idea to go somewhere and complain about something that you know is wrong and then call all the people who just had to remind you that you were wrong, idiots.
|
|
|
| supeg |
haha I know they pull mid 13's at zero elevation, our elevation here sucks, I was just breaking your nuts.
Yah Ill prob end up taking it off, hopefully I can go down and show them so i dont have to take a day off of work to go to court.
quote: Originally posted by 95EagleAWD
Low 14s? Please... it's high 13s. ;)
I've had a friend get his ass kicked by the cops too. Granted, he tossed a coke can into the window of their cruiser, but still.
Yeah, if you take it off, you shouldn't have to pay the ticket.
|
|
|
| 3gec |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
Yah Ill prob end up taking it off, hopefully I can go down and show them so i dont have to take a day off of work to go to court.
We are the total morons / idiots... mmm I was wrong and am mad at cops because I was wrong. (And yes I read the thing where you said hopefully I can go down so I don't have to take a day off) but now you Most likely will have to take a day off work to fight it, because you were wrong and lose more money by not going to work to fight a ticket that is valid than just paying it like you are supposed to because once again you were in the wrong.
Makes sense.
Next time I get a speeding ticket I think i am going to to down to the courthouse and ask them if I can get off of that speeding ticket because clearly I am not driving my car right now, therefor I am no longer speeding. I learnt my lesson can I get off that fine. |
|
|
| 95EagleAWD |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
haha I know they pull mid 13's at zero elevation, our elevation here sucks, I was just breaking your nuts.
Yah Ill prob end up taking it off, hopefully I can go down and show them so i dont have to take a day off of work to go to court.
They pull 13s here too. Bone stock. |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
Still cannot read? If you read the thread then you wouldn't have said what you said.
Please quote where I said I hate cops..
Please, I have had like 3 of my past vehicles broken into, of course nothing was ever found.
I have bigtime respect for cops that serve and protect, but ZERO who pull someone over when they are in a bad mood with a chip on there shoulder. I was pulled over at 6pm, go out tommorow and tell me how dark it is at 6pm. They did it to be dicks plain and simple, jealousy, or whatever there motovation was, i do not think the guy checks out every car he drives by in broad daylight looking for a licence plate light... The only way he would see it is if he was 5 feet away looking for something to bust me for...
Yes I am calling you along with the other morons that said "You should have been nice, then you would have gotten out of the tickets" TOTAL MORONS/IDIOTS. Like I said again, I was rude to the one guy AFTER I was told I was getting tickets....
I agree with you on one point, I hope as well someone steals it! I am selling it soon, but if someone steals it and wreaks/parts it I will get full apraised value for it :asshole:
Like has been said, if you remove the tint, you should at least get it reduced if not wiped. I also don't reccomend commiting perjury. It's not that cops don't ever lie, but consider who a judge is more likely to believe, a cop or some "punk"? I say "punk" because judges are usually old, and we all know what most old people would think of a bright orange truck with a showoff paint job, and he'll likely see you as a punk regardless of facts.
Being nice probably wouldn't have gotten you out of tickets, but it might have. Just because you've been told you're getting them doesn't mean a cop can't change his mind. But the 45 minute delay was probably unecessary and brought on by your rudeness. If there was no reason to be pulled over, fine. But you WERE in violation of the law.
As for "how dark is it at 6PM?" What does it matter? You said yourself they were scoping out your truck at BP's. Nowhere does it say cops have to catch you at night to give you a licence plate light ticket. If your argument would be that you never drive during official night, then run to court and tell them that, but I doubt they'll care/believe you. A cop could pull up to your vehicle that's parked anywhere public and walk right up to it, look around it, for whatever reason they want, and make a mental note of any violation, then pull you over days later and make sure it's still illegal and write tickets. How they say that you're missing a light is irrelevant, so you can get that out of your mind already.
You'll likely still have to go to court. Visiting the cop shop usually doesn't help. But if you have the time, it couldn't hurt. Some supervisors will do that kind of thing, some won't.
As far as burden of proof goes, they only have to show that it's more likely you had tint then didn't, and if they do, then you have to rebut and show it's less likely you had it. That may mean that in the judges estimation, there's a 51% chance you broke the law and only 49% chance you didn't. A cop would need a reason to accuse you of having tint you didn't have. Perhaps he's just an ass, but that's still a reason, and something you'd likely have to prove since they have the ticket and their 2 stories to show it's more likely.
Besides, they can show up to court, say they were going to run your info and give you a warning until you were rude, at which point they issued the citations. The whole "i was only going to issue a warning" stunt worked wonders for me when I went to court. Although to be fair, I always intended to issue warnings since we had no quotas, and only was certain to issue tickets for major violations (like 40+km/h over, or parking on medians and stuff like that which ticks me off).
Won't effect your insurance I don't think, but you can always call them to find out. If you do decide to fight it, best of luck to you. If you bump into that cop you were rude to in court before you enter the courtroom, it would probably go a long way to make amends. Apologize and tell him you had a bad day or something, let him know who painted your truck, give him a card from PaintDruid if you have one. You might even sell your truck, but the point is to get him on your side or at least neutral, even if you still want to stomp his guts out. |
|
|
| Vive le Quebec |
Well actually, keep in mind the delays don't just delay you, but they keep the officer at roadside as well. And when they're issuing a ticket, they aren't just filling out the information, they're also doing a background check on you. Hence when they originally stop you it's a few minutes before they get out and chat with you, because they're usually running your plate to see if your vehicle is stolen, on BOLF (be on the lookout for), etc. If it is, well say hello to their little friend. If not, it's standard procedure, walk up to the window, get the proper documentation go back to the car. Then they radio in again all your details to get your facts...and remember, the telecoms people aren't just there for the one officer, they're also running info for all the other officers out there, so it could be a while, especially if they're busy answering phone calls in between. I've never heard of a cop who enjoys sitting in a car waiting...waiting is just as boring to them.
Anyways, just thought I'd throw that in, since there's this misconception that cops are illiterate and deliberately write tickets slowly just to piss people off. |
|
|
| 3gEdmonton |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
I was pulled over at 6pm, go out tommorow and tell me how dark it is at 6pm.
Regardless of what time and day it is your licence plate light was out so the ticket is valid plain out and simple same as for the tint what are you fighting against for? You know you were at fault was the cop an asshole.. yes/maybe but if you seriously wouldn't have been a dick back to the officer who was trying to make conversation you might have gotten off with a ticket or reduced fine (maybe).
Your justification on the time and day it seems like a "night time" hit and run is subjected to a lower penelty than a "day time" hit an run.. regardless its a hit an run, you are at fault you are at fault. I've had cop pull me over in vancouver, I had a photo copied licence plate on my car at that time and had the original in my car didn't want it to get wet. He could have given me a ticket if I was a complete dick to him (i'm sure he would have found a way to give me one). Cops are human and be glad they were doing their job in traffic enforcement. If you don't like the rules and regulations its simple just don't drive and ETS it. You spent enough money modding your truck will a $0.98 cent bulb but you over your budget? Give it a rest man just pay the tickets. |
|
|
| cbourbs |
| i just brought my car in from the states a while ago and it had tint on it. It passed federal and provincial inspection. I just got a tinting ticket. I told the cop it passed all it's inspections and he didn't really have anything to say about it. If i take it to court would i be able to get off on this, or could i go after the people who provincially inspected it. I was thinking that maybe in court i could get away with it this one time. the judge will still tell me to take if off though. |
|
|
| 3gEdmonton |
quote: Originally posted by cbourbs
i just brought my car in from the states a while ago and it had tint on it. It passed federal and provincial inspection. I just got a tinting ticket. I told the cop it passed all it's inspections and he didn't really have anything to say about it. If i take it to court would i be able to get off on this, or could i go after the people who provincially inspected it. I was thinking that maybe in court i could get away with it this one time. the judge will still tell me to take if off though.
one question did you honestly not know that tint in your front windows is illegal or is grounds for getting a ticket? If you can answer the question as NO then go ahead and take it to court then take it off. But if you said "Yes" then pay the ticket and shut up.. simple |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by cbourbs
i just brought my car in from the states a while ago and it had tint on it. It passed federal and provincial inspection. I just got a tinting ticket. I told the cop it passed all it's inspections and he didn't really have anything to say about it. If i take it to court would i be able to get off on this, or could i go after the people who provincially inspected it. I was thinking that maybe in court i could get away with it this one time. the judge will still tell me to take if off though.
There's no federal law on tint, so passing a federal inspection won't matter.
The purpose of the OOP is NOT to ensure the vehicle is legal, but to ensure the vehicle is safe.
quote: From http://www.infratrans.gov.ab.ca/Dri...Inspections.htm
The mechanical fitness portion of the OOP Vehicle Inspection involves virtually all vehicle components including fuel and exhaust systems, all electrical, engine controls, powertrain, driveline, steering, suspension, braking systems, wiring and lights, tires, glass, wipers and defrosters.
The vehicle must be maintained within Original Equipment Manufacturers standards or wear tolerances in order to pass the inspection.
Structural integrity inspections establish whether or not the vehicle's frame and/or body exhibit signs of major collision damage and/or repairs. They also examine the vehicle for corrosion in body or frame members. The OOP Vehicle Inspection may not be conclusive in determining previous crash history as the inspection technicians are certified automotive service technicians, not autobody collision repair technicians. If you suspect the vehicle has sustained major damage before you purchased it, you may wish to have the vehicle examined by a collision repair technician.
In other words, they don't check for tint, mudguards, or anything else which, while "illegal", is not going to be inherently "unsafe". As an example, you could have a police siren and mount red and blue flashing lights on your roof, and still pass the OOP. But you'd get pulled over and ticketed in a heartbeat.
Passing inspections don't resolve you from the responsibility of ensuring your vehicle complies with regulations. You could TRY going to court and saying "I didn't know. I assumed if it passed the OOP it was legal." Maybe the judge what cut you a break. But you can't go after anyone, and your excuse is invalid. Ignorance of the law is not a defence. |
|
|
| Bad Egg |
I think supeg has got the message by now, or at least I hope so.
Another poster mentioned the check on the vehicle and your record they do while they have you pulled over, and that is something that is more important than you may think. Just because the officer initially tells you that he pulled you over for an infraction, it does not mean you automatically are getting a ticket for that offence. For all supeg knows, while the french speaking officer was running his info he may have had every intention of giving him a warning. When supeg snotted off to the young officer that chance evaporated.
Yes, supeg, I read your posts, and in your first one you say that he took your driver's license back to the car after telling you what your violation was. Nowhere else do you specifically state that he said he was giving you two tickets. You seem to be just assuming that was what you were getting. I was in a similar situation recently when I was stopped and informed I was speeding, yet I was just one of several vehicles going the same speed on the highway. My car stands out as a relatively rare RHD and somehow he picked me instead of the Civic, Caravan or Silverado that were some of those in the same group.
When he put his lights on I first pointed to a parking lot up ahead for permission to pull in there since the road we were on had no shoulders and stopping there would have blocked traffic and been dangerous for the officer. He waved me in on my suggestion and I don't know if that act of mine had any bearing on the result and I didn't do it to suck up, but only because it seemed like the right thing to do. I did not argue with him and accepted the fact that I was due for a ticket because I was guilty, and it didn't matter what the other traffic was doing, today was my turn to pay.
After checking my info with the office(why don't RCMP have computers linked to the databases?), he asked me a couple of questions about my car, suggested a safer speed to avoid being stopped and let me go with no tickets. I don't believe he stopped me just to ask me about my car, but he was interested in it while we were there and supegs incident was likely as simple as that. I could have easily gotten pissed about being picked out of the crowd of cars doing the same thing, but that would not have changed the fact that I was guilty. I think that everyone wants to be treated with respect, no matter what their job, and I would have acted the same way even if I knew I was getting a ticket.
This time I am pretty sure that my actions contributed to the officer's leniency, but only the officer knows that for sure. I just know that the RCMP has given me a break the last couple of times I have been pulled over(that's 2X in a decade), and if for no other reasons than pure self defense it is in your best interest to give them a reasonable measure of respect.
That is a pretty spiffy paint job on the truck, btw... |
|
|
| JonJonPoPong |
Too much to read, but my sister got a license plate light out ticket before too, your responsible for checking all lights on your vehical before you drive anywhere.
However you can get off ususaly if you say "It was on when I left because I saw it on, it must of gone off while I was driving"
Since there is no resonable way for you to check while driven that your plate light was out you could get off, but since the cops know ur plate light was out to start with you wont. |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by JonJonPoPong
Too much to read, but my sister got a license plate light out ticket before too, your responsible for checking all lights on your vehical before you drive anywhere.
However you can get off ususaly if you say "It was on when I left because I saw it on, it must of gone off while I was driving"
Since there is no resonable way for you to check while driven that your plate light was out you could get off, but since the cops know ur plate light was out to start with you wont.
Again, he never said it was out, he said he didn't have one. |
|
|
| 3gEdmonton |
quote: Originally posted by dtjohnst
Again, he never said it was out, he said he didn't have one.
Whats the harm of $0.98 bulb? :dunno:
Here's a thought how about a "licence plate light mod" for his next project on his truck? :thumbup: |
|
|
| supeg |
No spot for it to go, its an aftermarket rollpan and im not drilling into it.
Selling my truck soon anyways, next owner can do it if he wants. |
|
|
| 3gEdmonton |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
No spot for it to go, its an aftermarket rollpan and im not drilling into it.
Then you've answered your own question I think everyone knows you pay the consequences for modding if it doesn’t adhere to traffic/vehicle laws. So if you don't want to do it b/c you don't want to drill a hole or don't have a spot for it to go, then don't complain about it if you get a ticket for it regardless of what time of day it is. You broke the law plain out and simple so abide by it. |
|
|
| supeg |
I didn't ask a question....
My rant was not pertaining to the law itself, I ranted because the Cops have nothing better to do then to inspect every part of my ride looking for an infraction to give because they are Jelous haters plain and simple.
Cannot tell there is a bulb there or its on unless you get on your hands and knees and look.
Do not want to argue anymore so just don't worry about it, and enjoy your STI, I am prob getting one soon as well.
quote: Originally posted by 3gEdmonton
Then you've answered your own question I think everyone knows you pay the consequences for modding if it doesn’t adhere to traffic/vehicle laws. So if you don't want to do it b/c you don't want to drill a hole or don't have a spot for it to go, then don't complain about it if you get a ticket for it regardless of what time of day it is. You broke the law plain out and simple so abide by it.
|
|
|
| 3gEdmonton |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
Do not want to argue anymore so just don't worry about it, and enjoy your STI, I am prob getting one soon as well.
I am fun car to drive. Bonus it comes with a licence plate light and its pretty bright lol
Just giving you a hard time man take it easy. It happens to everyone it was just you that day. |
|
|
| Bad Egg |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
...snip...I ranted because the Cops have nothing better to do then to inspect every part of my ride looking for an infraction to give because they are Jelous haters plain and simple.
...snip...
:rolleyes: |
|
|
| Vive le Quebec |
quote: Originally posted by Bad Egg
After checking my info with the office(why don't RCMP have computers linked to the databases?), he asked me a couple of questions about my car, suggested a safer speed to avoid being stopped and let me go with no tickets.
Most rural RCMP districts don't have a way of receiving the signal required for in-car computers...Red Deer, Sherwood Park, and some of the larger "urban" detachments are starting to introduce computers into their cars. St. Albert just received a bunch a couple months ago. |
|
|
| 95EagleAWD |
quote: Originally posted by supeg
My rant was not pertaining to the law itself, I ranted because the Cops have nothing better to do then to inspect every part of my ride looking for an infraction to give because they are Jelous haters plain and simple.
:rolleyes: |
|
|
| Blaine B. |
quote: Originally posted by dtjohnst
The purpose of the OOP is NOT to ensure the vehicle is legal, but to ensure the vehicle is safe.
In other words, they don't check for tint, mudguards, or anything else which, while "illegal", is not going to be inherently "unsafe".
That flies in the face of what you quoted entirely:
quote: The mechanical fitness portion of the OOP Vehicle Inspection involves virtually all vehicle components including fuel and exhaust systems, all electrical, engine controls, powertrain, driveline, steering, suspension, braking systems, wiring and lights, tires, glass, wipers and defrosters.
The vehicle must be maintained within Original Equipment Manufacturers standards or wear tolerances in order to pass the inspection.
Show me an OEM front window tinted vehicle sold in Canada in the last 20 years.
I think cbourbs has a shot if he can prove the vehicle was tinted at time of inspection.
Isn't the big reason tint is outlawed on the front windows fo safety of the driver? I have never recieved a definitive answer. Heard a bunch of hearsay from law enforcement I respect and also from law enforcement officials who have yet to earn my respect. |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by Blaine B.
That flies in the face of what you quoted entirely:
Show me an OEM front window tinted vehicle sold in Canada in the last 20 years.
I think cbourbs has a shot if he can prove the vehicle was tinted at time of inspection.
Isn't the big reason tint is outlawed on the front windows fo safety of the driver? I have never recieved a definitive answer. Heard a bunch of hearsay from law enforcement I respect and also from law enforcement officials who have yet to earn my respect.
Look at it again. "Original Equipment Manufacturers standards or wear tolerances". Is there a "standard" or "wear tolerance" on tint? It doesn't say the car must be entirely composed of "OEM" components, merely that it must meet "OEM" standards. Has tint weakened your windshield? Likely not, therefore the "standard" has been met. If your car has a crack in the windshield, it will likely need to be replaced, though depending on what the OEM tolerance is maybe it could be repaired instead.
Remember, tint isn't illegal everywhere, so if OEM said something AGAINST tint being safe on their windows, they'd probably lose business in those areas.
Is tint unsafe? It COULD be under specific conditions. It's illegal for many reasons, most of which are arguable. Afterall, that's why different places have different set limits on tint. What one legislative body finds "unsafe" another finds "reasonable".
If a winow is "smoked", it has less problems. Smoked glass MAY reduce visibility in situations where visibility is already reduced, mainly the view INTO the vehicle. Pedestrians and other drivers often believe in eye contact before doing things, and even if you don't (I know some people have said they don't care about eye contact), other people do.
But even more importantly. Let's say you get in an accident, car rolls, someone is thrown from it and is lying beside it. Police and FD/Paras show up on the scene and the car is on fire, they drag the one person away to safety. Now, do they break out the center punch or asp baton and break the glass to drag out the other passengers, at risk to themselves or not? Well, if your window is tinted darkly, maybe they can't see inside, so now what? Do they risk their lives "in case", or sit back and say "stupid ricer shouldn't have tinted his windows"? It makes life difficult.
As for tinting in the form of film, that film can effect how a window breaks. Is it possible that the film will help hold bits of glass together preventing them from slicing and killing someone inside the car? Definately. It not only can but has happened. But it could also cause problems in cases where someone would penetrate the window and have it give way. It may hold firm and cause damage. Or it may cause the window to fragment into larget chunks creating more of a hazard then small bits.
So which is more likely? That tint will hurt people or help them? Studies have been done. Results are largely inconclusive. The result? Alberta has decided it's safer to have NO tint. Why? That was the opinion of the lawmakers. If you disagree with it strongly, write your MLA and your MP. Use your power as a citizen in a Republic to try and effect changes you want to see.
Regardless, it's not looked for in OOP inspections. Get one done and ask to see a copy of the Government provided forms that the mechanic fills out. Nowhere on there is tint mentioned. It's fill-in-the-blank, and tint isn't on there.
Should it be? Maybe, but that's not the purpose of this discussion. As it stands, the OOP is designed to ensure you're car won't fall apart on you and that it meets BASIC requirements. Working speedo, working steering, solid frame, panels that aren't so rusted they may fall off, suspension that works, exhaust system in place that works (even if it's loud), working brakes, tires that aren't overly worn, etc.
I agree entirely that an OOP inspection SHOULD determine if a vehicle complies with all laws. I was in shock when I found out tint on the front windows was illegal since mine had it when it went through an OOP, but I have a copy of the inspection form from mine and that question isn't asked.
As for cops issuing tickets because they're jealous, someone needs to get over it. Cops have better things to do then issue tickets because they're jealous. A uniform gets more chicks than a truck will, so there's no need for them to be jealous to the point of bringing someone down. It's a nice truck, no denying it.....but it's JUST a truck all the same. I doubt jealousy would go that far. Maybe a poor kid driving a beater taking a baseball bat to it for parking on a median in a parking lot or something out of jealousy and anger that you think your special because it's a nice truck, but cops issuing tickets? Seriously man, cops aren't that petty. I don't know anyone who is. You need to get off the horse. |
|
|
| snugs |
| Just a thought, but what was the lights on time for that day (was it after 6pm?) and are the license plate lights on the lightning tied in to the headlight so that if the headlights are off the license plate lights are off too? I seem to remember that was the case with my old GT, no headlights = no license plate light. :dunno: |
|
|
| Bad Egg |
snugs,
I have read this whole thread now, and somewhere in it the truck owner states that he has no license plate light at all,(body mods) or even a place to put one. |
|
|
| snugs |
quote: Originally posted by Bad Egg
snugs,
I have read this whole thread now, and somewhere in it the truck owner states that he has no license plate light at all,(body mods) or even a place to put one.
If the lights are missing off the bumper and he was cited for not having them installed that's one thing, but if he was cited for them not being lit at a time when they were not required to be lit that's something completely different. :) |
|
|
| dtjohnst |
quote: Originally posted by snugs
Just a thought, but what was the lights on time for that day (was it after 6pm?) and are the license plate lights on the lightning tied in to the headlight so that if the headlights are off the license plate lights are off too? I seem to remember that was the case with my old GT, no headlights = no license plate light. :dunno:
That's what the law says: the light must be on when the headlights are on, which to some may seem a defense given the hour, but the Rules of the Road state you must have your lights on at night or when visibility is reduced.
Anyways, I'd already pointed out 3 times before Bad Egg did that he said he didn't have one, not that it wasn't on. He also mentioned the time he was out at.
The fact is, having the proper lights but having them burnt out will usually NOT result in a ticket. In cases like that, a peace officer will usually use 66(1)(e) of the TSA, and order it repaired. If they chose to issue the citation instead of using 66(1)(e), appearing in court an | | | | |